A clinical study of inferior alveolar nerve damage caused by Carnoy’s solution used as a complementary therapeutic agent in a cystic lesion

Jo, Hyun-Jun; Kim, Hee-Youl; Kang, Dong-Cheol; Leem, Dae-Ho; Baek, Jin-A; Ko, Seung-O

doi:10.1186/s40902-020-00257-4

Maxillofacial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery

Table 4 Raw data

From: A clinical study of inferior alveolar nerve damage caused by Carnoy’s solution used as a complementary therapeutic agent in a cystic lesion

No.	Diagnosis	Sex	Age	Name initial	Follow-up period (month)	Invasion size	Preoperative NRS	Right after operation NRS	Follow-up NRS
1	OKC	F	26	OSB	32	2	10	2	2
2	OKC	F	25	KSE	55	3	10	7	9
3	OKC	F	16	KJH	30	2	10	10	10
4	OKC	F	13	HSB	22	2	10	3	10
5	OKC	M	62	BBJ	19	1	10	10	10
6	OKC	M	62	YSI	16	2	10	10	10
7	OKC	M	54	SHI	23	1	10	10	10
8	OKC	M	46	LTK	33	2	10	5	5
9	OKC	M	46	SYH	56	2	10	10	10
10	OKC	M	45	CCH	54	3	10	2	2
11	OKC	M	38	LSH	33	2	10	7	9
12	OKC	M	37	OJW	24	2	10	2	5
13	OKC	M	20	BJW	19	1	10	8	10
14	OKC	M	11	LSH	51	2	10	10	10
15	UAM	F	23	KJE	63	2	10	3	10
16	UAM	F	18	LYJ	19	3	10	7	8
17	UAM	F	17	JJS	20	2	10	10	10
18	UAM	M	53	KK	57	3	10	3	4
19	UAM	M	17	MJB	22	3	10	8	8
20	DC	F	57	JSN	42	2	10	10	10
21	DC	F	55	JSD	37	2	10	9	9
22	DC	F	46	CJ	51	2	10	8	8
23	DC	F	30	LJA	24	1	10	10	10
24	DC	M	76	PKB	23	2	10	10	10
25	DC	M	59	BSW	26	3	10	3	3
26	DC	M	58	LNJ	60	1	10	10	10
27	DC	M	56	CYH	66	3	10	9	10
28	DC	M	56	HBK	39	2	10	10	10
29	DC	M	55	BWH	34	1	10	10	10
30	DC	M	54	LYJ	36	1	10	9	10
31	DC	M	53	OJK	52	1	10	10	10
32	DC	M	53	KKH	32	1	10	8	8
33	DC	M	52	KHK	21	2	10	10	10
34	DC	M	50	LJE	24	1	10	10	10
35	DC	M	50	KDH	19	2	10	10	10
36	DC	M	44	KDY	11	3	10	5	7
37	DC	M	40	JSK	34	1	10	10	10
38	DC	M	39	JIC	49	3	10	5	7
39	DC	M	39	KSW	51	3	10	7	9
40	DC	M	36	KYH	29	1	10	10	10
41	DC	M	35	KH	51	2	10	10	10
42	DC	M	34	SWM	44	3	10	9	9
43	DC	M	33	JYH	41	3	10	9	9
44	DC	M	30	KYM	38	2	10	10	10
45	DC	M	29	JJH	33	2	10	10	10
46	DC	M	28	SH	31	1	10	9	9
47	DC	M	28	OSH	35	1	10	10	10
48	DC	M	23	LJH	28	1	10	10	10
49	DC	M	17	KHD	59	1	10	8	9
50	RC	F	61	PYH	35	1	10	10	10
51	RC	F	46	OMJ	19	3	10	7	7
52	RC	F	43	JYH	37	1	10	10	10
53	RC	F	40	LSA	41	1	10	10	10
54	RC	F	35	OHL	58	3	10	6	6
55	RC	F	34	KHK	65	3	10	7	7
56	RC	F	32	LHJ	51	3	10	5	5
57	RC	F	31	CHS	43	1	10	10	10
58	RC	F	23	PDS	10	3	10	7	7
59	RC	M	59	LMS	47	1	10	10	10
60	RC	M	59	CBS	29	1	10	8	10
61	RC	M	52	KHK	27	1	10	10	10
62	RC	M	51	PYK	55	3	10	7	7
63	RC	M	50	HSK	23	1	10	10	10
64	RC	M	49	NSK	39	3	10	5	5
65	RC	M	49	LYC	34	3	10	6	7
66	RC	M	43	PSM	27	1	10	9	10
67	RC	M	42	LDJ	49	1	10	10	10
68	RC	M	41	OYM	51	1	10	10	10
69	RC	M	39	PSH	40	3	10	3	3
70	RC	M	37	LJY	58	2	10	5	7
71	RC	M	36	KJW	38	2	10	4	6
72	RC	M	32	PSS	37	1	10	10	10
73	RC	M	32	WSD	22	1	10	10	10
74	RC	M	30	CHJ	48	3	10	8	10
75	RC	M	21	SYK	31	2	10	2	10
76	RC	M	19	JDI	24	1	10	10	10
77	RC	M	16	LSB	40	3	10	7	7

Back to article page

No.	Diagnosis	Sex	Age	Name initial	Follow-up period (month)	Invasion size	Preoperative NRS	Right after operation NRS	Follow-up NRS
1	OKC	F	26	OSB	32	2	10	2	2
2	OKC	F	25	KSE	55	3	10	7	9
3	OKC	F	16	KJH	30	2	10	10	10
4	OKC	F	13	HSB	22	2	10	3	10
5	OKC	M	62	BBJ	19	1	10	10	10
6	OKC	M	62	YSI	16	2	10	10	10
7	OKC	M	54	SHI	23	1	10	10	10
8	OKC	M	46	LTK	33	2	10	5	5
9	OKC	M	46	SYH	56	2	10	10	10
10	OKC	M	45	CCH	54	3	10	2	2
11	OKC	M	38	LSH	33	2	10	7	9
12	OKC	M	37	OJW	24	2	10	2	5
13	OKC	M	20	BJW	19	1	10	8	10
14	OKC	M	11	LSH	51	2	10	10	10
15	UAM	F	23	KJE	63	2	10	3	10
16	UAM	F	18	LYJ	19	3	10	7	8
17	UAM	F	17	JJS	20	2	10	10	10
18	UAM	M	53	KK	57	3	10	3	4
19	UAM	M	17	MJB	22	3	10	8	8
20	DC	F	57	JSN	42	2	10	10	10
21	DC	F	55	JSD	37	2	10	9	9
22	DC	F	46	CJ	51	2	10	8	8
23	DC	F	30	LJA	24	1	10	10	10
24	DC	M	76	PKB	23	2	10	10	10
25	DC	M	59	BSW	26	3	10	3	3
26	DC	M	58	LNJ	60	1	10	10	10
27	DC	M	56	CYH	66	3	10	9	10
28	DC	M	56	HBK	39	2	10	10	10
29	DC	M	55	BWH	34	1	10	10	10
30	DC	M	54	LYJ	36	1	10	9	10
31	DC	M	53	OJK	52	1	10	10	10
32	DC	M	53	KKH	32	1	10	8	8
33	DC	M	52	KHK	21	2	10	10	10
34	DC	M	50	LJE	24	1	10	10	10
35	DC	M	50	KDH	19	2	10	10	10
36	DC	M	44	KDY	11	3	10	5	7
37	DC	M	40	JSK	34	1	10	10	10
38	DC	M	39	JIC	49	3	10	5	7
39	DC	M	39	KSW	51	3	10	7	9
40	DC	M	36	KYH	29	1	10	10	10
41	DC	M	35	KH	51	2	10	10	10
42	DC	M	34	SWM	44	3	10	9	9
43	DC	M	33	JYH	41	3	10	9	9
44	DC	M	30	KYM	38	2	10	10	10
45	DC	M	29	JJH	33	2	10	10	10
46	DC	M	28	SH	31	1	10	9	9
47	DC	M	28	OSH	35	1	10	10	10
48	DC	M	23	LJH	28	1	10	10	10
49	DC	M	17	KHD	59	1	10	8	9
50	RC	F	61	PYH	35	1	10	10	10
51	RC	F	46	OMJ	19	3	10	7	7
52	RC	F	43	JYH	37	1	10	10	10
53	RC	F	40	LSA	41	1	10	10	10
54	RC	F	35	OHL	58	3	10	6	6
55	RC	F	34	KHK	65	3	10	7	7
56	RC	F	32	LHJ	51	3	10	5	5
57	RC	F	31	CHS	43	1	10	10	10
58	RC	F	23	PDS	10	3	10	7	7
59	RC	M	59	LMS	47	1	10	10	10
60	RC	M	59	CBS	29	1	10	8	10
61	RC	M	52	KHK	27	1	10	10	10
62	RC	M	51	PYK	55	3	10	7	7
63	RC	M	50	HSK	23	1	10	10	10
64	RC	M	49	NSK	39	3	10	5	5
65	RC	M	49	LYC	34	3	10	6	7
66	RC	M	43	PSM	27	1	10	9	10
67	RC	M	42	LDJ	49	1	10	10	10
68	RC	M	41	OYM	51	1	10	10	10
69	RC	M	39	PSH	40	3	10	3	3
70	RC	M	37	LJY	58	2	10	5	7
71	RC	M	36	KJW	38	2	10	4	6
72	RC	M	32	PSS	37	1	10	10	10
73	RC	M	32	WSD	22	1	10	10	10
74	RC	M	30	CHJ	48	3	10	8	10
75	RC	M	21	SYK	31	2	10	2	10
76	RC	M	19	JDI	24	1	10	10	10
77	RC	M	16	LSB	40	3	10	7	7

No.	Diagnosis	Sex	Age	Name initial	Follow-up period (month)	Invasion size	Preoperative NRS	Right after operation NRS	Follow-up NRS
1	OKC	F	26	OSB	32	2	10	2	2
2	OKC	F	25	KSE	55	3	10	7	9
3	OKC	F	16	KJH	30	2	10	10	10
4	OKC	F	13	HSB	22	2	10	3	10
5	OKC	M	62	BBJ	19	1	10	10	10
6	OKC	M	62	YSI	16	2	10	10	10
7	OKC	M	54	SHI	23	1	10	10	10
8	OKC	M	46	LTK	33	2	10	5	5
9	OKC	M	46	SYH	56	2	10	10	10
10	OKC	M	45	CCH	54	3	10	2	2
11	OKC	M	38	LSH	33	2	10	7	9
12	OKC	M	37	OJW	24	2	10	2	5
13	OKC	M	20	BJW	19	1	10	8	10
14	OKC	M	11	LSH	51	2	10	10	10
15	UAM	F	23	KJE	63	2	10	3	10
16	UAM	F	18	LYJ	19	3	10	7	8
17	UAM	F	17	JJS	20	2	10	10	10
18	UAM	M	53	KK	57	3	10	3	4
19	UAM	M	17	MJB	22	3	10	8	8
20	DC	F	57	JSN	42	2	10	10	10
21	DC	F	55	JSD	37	2	10	9	9
22	DC	F	46	CJ	51	2	10	8	8
23	DC	F	30	LJA	24	1	10	10	10
24	DC	M	76	PKB	23	2	10	10	10
25	DC	M	59	BSW	26	3	10	3	3
26	DC	M	58	LNJ	60	1	10	10	10
27	DC	M	56	CYH	66	3	10	9	10
28	DC	M	56	HBK	39	2	10	10	10
29	DC	M	55	BWH	34	1	10	10	10
30	DC	M	54	LYJ	36	1	10	9	10
31	DC	M	53	OJK	52	1	10	10	10
32	DC	M	53	KKH	32	1	10	8	8
33	DC	M	52	KHK	21	2	10	10	10
34	DC	M	50	LJE	24	1	10	10	10
35	DC	M	50	KDH	19	2	10	10	10
36	DC	M	44	KDY	11	3	10	5	7
37	DC	M	40	JSK	34	1	10	10	10
38	DC	M	39	JIC	49	3	10	5	7
39	DC	M	39	KSW	51	3	10	7	9
40	DC	M	36	KYH	29	1	10	10	10
41	DC	M	35	KH	51	2	10	10	10
42	DC	M	34	SWM	44	3	10	9	9
43	DC	M	33	JYH	41	3	10	9	9
44	DC	M	30	KYM	38	2	10	10	10
45	DC	M	29	JJH	33	2	10	10	10
46	DC	M	28	SH	31	1	10	9	9
47	DC	M	28	OSH	35	1	10	10	10
48	DC	M	23	LJH	28	1	10	10	10
49	DC	M	17	KHD	59	1	10	8	9
50	RC	F	61	PYH	35	1	10	10	10
51	RC	F	46	OMJ	19	3	10	7	7
52	RC	F	43	JYH	37	1	10	10	10
53	RC	F	40	LSA	41	1	10	10	10
54	RC	F	35	OHL	58	3	10	6	6
55	RC	F	34	KHK	65	3	10	7	7
56	RC	F	32	LHJ	51	3	10	5	5
57	RC	F	31	CHS	43	1	10	10	10
58	RC	F	23	PDS	10	3	10	7	7
59	RC	M	59	LMS	47	1	10	10	10
60	RC	M	59	CBS	29	1	10	8	10
61	RC	M	52	KHK	27	1	10	10	10
62	RC	M	51	PYK	55	3	10	7	7
63	RC	M	50	HSK	23	1	10	10	10
64	RC	M	49	NSK	39	3	10	5	5
65	RC	M	49	LYC	34	3	10	6	7
66	RC	M	43	PSM	27	1	10	9	10
67	RC	M	42	LDJ	49	1	10	10	10
68	RC	M	41	OYM	51	1	10	10	10
69	RC	M	39	PSH	40	3	10	3	3
70	RC	M	37	LJY	58	2	10	5	7
71	RC	M	36	KJW	38	2	10	4	6
72	RC	M	32	PSS	37	1	10	10	10
73	RC	M	32	WSD	22	1	10	10	10
74	RC	M	30	CHJ	48	3	10	8	10
75	RC	M	21	SYK	31	2	10	2	10
76	RC	M	19	JDI	24	1	10	10	10
77	RC	M	16	LSB	40	3	10	7	7

No.	Diagnosis	Sex	Age	Name initial	Follow-up period (month)	Invasion size	Preoperative NRS	Right after operation NRS	Follow-up NRS
1	OKC	F	26	OSB	32	2	10	2	2
2	OKC	F	25	KSE	55	3	10	7	9
3	OKC	F	16	KJH	30	2	10	10	10
4	OKC	F	13	HSB	22	2	10	3	10
5	OKC	M	62	BBJ	19	1	10	10	10
6	OKC	M	62	YSI	16	2	10	10	10
7	OKC	M	54	SHI	23	1	10	10	10
8	OKC	M	46	LTK	33	2	10	5	5
9	OKC	M	46	SYH	56	2	10	10	10
10	OKC	M	45	CCH	54	3	10	2	2
11	OKC	M	38	LSH	33	2	10	7	9
12	OKC	M	37	OJW	24	2	10	2	5
13	OKC	M	20	BJW	19	1	10	8	10
14	OKC	M	11	LSH	51	2	10	10	10
15	UAM	F	23	KJE	63	2	10	3	10
16	UAM	F	18	LYJ	19	3	10	7	8
17	UAM	F	17	JJS	20	2	10	10	10
18	UAM	M	53	KK	57	3	10	3	4
19	UAM	M	17	MJB	22	3	10	8	8
20	DC	F	57	JSN	42	2	10	10	10
21	DC	F	55	JSD	37	2	10	9	9
22	DC	F	46	CJ	51	2	10	8	8
23	DC	F	30	LJA	24	1	10	10	10
24	DC	M	76	PKB	23	2	10	10	10
25	DC	M	59	BSW	26	3	10	3	3
26	DC	M	58	LNJ	60	1	10	10	10
27	DC	M	56	CYH	66	3	10	9	10
28	DC	M	56	HBK	39	2	10	10	10
29	DC	M	55	BWH	34	1	10	10	10
30	DC	M	54	LYJ	36	1	10	9	10
31	DC	M	53	OJK	52	1	10	10	10
32	DC	M	53	KKH	32	1	10	8	8
33	DC	M	52	KHK	21	2	10	10	10
34	DC	M	50	LJE	24	1	10	10	10
35	DC	M	50	KDH	19	2	10	10	10
36	DC	M	44	KDY	11	3	10	5	7
37	DC	M	40	JSK	34	1	10	10	10
38	DC	M	39	JIC	49	3	10	5	7
39	DC	M	39	KSW	51	3	10	7	9
40	DC	M	36	KYH	29	1	10	10	10
41	DC	M	35	KH	51	2	10	10	10
42	DC	M	34	SWM	44	3	10	9	9
43	DC	M	33	JYH	41	3	10	9	9
44	DC	M	30	KYM	38	2	10	10	10
45	DC	M	29	JJH	33	2	10	10	10
46	DC	M	28	SH	31	1	10	9	9
47	DC	M	28	OSH	35	1	10	10	10
48	DC	M	23	LJH	28	1	10	10	10
49	DC	M	17	KHD	59	1	10	8	9
50	RC	F	61	PYH	35	1	10	10	10
51	RC	F	46	OMJ	19	3	10	7	7
52	RC	F	43	JYH	37	1	10	10	10
53	RC	F	40	LSA	41	1	10	10	10
54	RC	F	35	OHL	58	3	10	6	6
55	RC	F	34	KHK	65	3	10	7	7
56	RC	F	32	LHJ	51	3	10	5	5
57	RC	F	31	CHS	43	1	10	10	10
58	RC	F	23	PDS	10	3	10	7	7
59	RC	M	59	LMS	47	1	10	10	10
60	RC	M	59	CBS	29	1	10	8	10
61	RC	M	52	KHK	27	1	10	10	10
62	RC	M	51	PYK	55	3	10	7	7
63	RC	M	50	HSK	23	1	10	10	10
64	RC	M	49	NSK	39	3	10	5	5
65	RC	M	49	LYC	34	3	10	6	7
66	RC	M	43	PSM	27	1	10	9	10
67	RC	M	42	LDJ	49	1	10	10	10
68	RC	M	41	OYM	51	1	10	10	10
69	RC	M	39	PSH	40	3	10	3	3
70	RC	M	37	LJY	58	2	10	5	7
71	RC	M	36	KJW	38	2	10	4	6
72	RC	M	32	PSS	37	1	10	10	10
73	RC	M	32	WSD	22	1	10	10	10
74	RC	M	30	CHJ	48	3	10	8	10
75	RC	M	21	SYK	31	2	10	2	10
76	RC	M	19	JDI	24	1	10	10	10
77	RC	M	16	LSB	40	3	10	7	7